Wisconsin
(920) 854-3214
Missouri
(314) 266-2286

ERISA Insurance Disputes

ERISA Insurance Disputes

Are you facing unexpected challenges with your ERISA insurance claim? Dealing with a claim dispute can feel overwhelming, but you don’t have to handle it alone. At the Law Offices of Phillip A. Tatlow, LLC, our experienced ERISA lawyers can make all the difference for you. We know the law well and can prepare a strong appeal if your claim is denied. We can also talk to plan administrators for you, fight for your rights in court if necessary, and work hard to get you the benefits you’re entitled to. Contact us now for a free initial consultation to learn more. 

What is ERISA?

The Employee Retirement Income Security ACT (ERISA) is a federal law that came into effect in 1974. ERISA sets standards for most voluntarily established pension and health plans for private industry workers, providing protections for individuals with these plans. This applies to most employer-sponsored health and retirement plans. 

The law requires plans to provide participants with plan information, including important details about plan features and funding. It also sets minimum participation, vesting, benefit accrual, and funding standards. ERISA grants you certain rights if you participate in a covered plan. These rights include the ability to sue for benefits and breaches of fiduciary duty. ERISA also demands accountability from plan fiduciaries, who must act in the best interests of plan participants.

Rights and Protections Under ERISA

ERISA grants you several rights and protections if you have a health or retirement plan through your job. First, ERISA says you have the right to important information about your plan. This includes details about plan rules, financial information, and how the plan works. You also have the right to access documents about your plan for free or at a low cost. These documents include summaries of plan benefits and annual financial reports.

If there’s a problem with your benefits, ERISA outlines the process you can use for appeals and grievances. So, for instance, if your plan’s administrators deny your benefits, you can ask them to reconsider their decision. You also have the right to sue for benefits or for breaches of fiduciary duty. A breach of fiduciary duty occurs when those managing your plan act in their own interests instead of your interests or at your expense.

The ERISA Claims Process

The ERISA claims process begins when you submit a claim to your health or retirement plan. This involves filling out forms and submitting any needed documents. Once they receive your claim, the plan’s administrators have 90 days to review it and decide whether you qualify for benefits.

If the administrators approve your claim, they will start giving you the benefits you applied for. However, they must explain their reasoning in writing if they deny your claim. This explanation must specify why they denied your claim and what you can do next.

If you disagree with the denial, ERISA lets you appeal the decision. To do this, you can submit more information and argue why you should receive the benefits. The plan administrators must review your appeal carefully before making a final decision.

If your plan administrator still denies your benefits after the appeal, ERISA gives you the right to take legal action. This means you can go to court to fight for your benefits. Knowledgeable legal representation is essential when dealing with ERISA claim denials and appeals.

Common Types of ERISA Insurance Disputes

Many disagreements can arise between plan participants and administrators in ERISA insurance claims. These disputes usually stem from misunderstandings of the plan’s coverage or disagreements over how the law applies. Below, we explore common situations that can result in these disputes:

Denied Health Insurance Claims

Some disputes arise when people make claims under their ERISA-covered health insurance plans, and those claims get denied. This often happens when plan administrators decide a treatment is not medically necessary or is experimental. For example, your plan administrator might deny your claim for a new type of surgery, stating that the procedure doesn’t fall under covered treatments. If this occurs, you might need to work with a lawyer to argue why the treatment is necessary and should be covered.

Disability Benefit Disputes

Disputes over disability benefits are common. If you become unable to work, you might apply for disability benefits through your employer’s plan. The plan’s administrators might deny your claim, arguing that you don’t meet their definition of “disabled.” This might force you to prove the extent of your disability, which often requires extensive medical evidence and professional legal help.

Life Insurance Claim Denials

Life insurance disputes can arise if your plan administrator refuses to pay out a death benefit. The administrator might claim that the cause of death is not covered by the policy or that there were misrepresentations in your initial application. If this happens, you might need to contest the denial and prove that the death should be covered under the plan terms. This can be difficult and overwhelming during a period of significant emotional distress, so it’s wise to seek legal representation in these situations.

Pension and Retirement Benefit Issues

Disputes over pension and retirement benefits are also common. You might become involved in a dispute if your plan administrator calculates your benefits incorrectly or refuses to fully recognize your years of service. Addressing these issues requires interpreting complex plan documents and possibly challenging the plan’s calculations to ensure that you receive the full benefits you’ve earned. A lawyer can handle all this legal legwork for you so you can enjoy your retirement in peace.

What to Do If You’re Involved in an ERISA Dispute

Dealing with an ERISA dispute can feel overwhelming, but taking the right steps can greatly improve your chances of resolving the issue in your favor. Here’s a list of actions you can take if you find yourself in the middle of an ERISA dispute:

  • Gather all relevant documents related to your plan and the dispute.
  • Request a written explanation of the denial from the plan administrator.
  • Record any communications with plan administrators or other involved parties.
  • Identify the specific reasons for the denial of benefits.
  • Consult with a lawyer who specializes in ERISA disputes.
  • Review your plan’s summary plan description (SPD) with your attorney.
  • Submit your appeal within the plan’s required timeframe.
  • Keep a detailed record of all expenses related to the dispute.

How an ERISA Attorney Can Help

When you’re facing an ERISA claim dispute, having an experienced ERISA lawyer by your side can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case. Here are some ways an ERISA attorney can assist you:

  • Analyzing your plan’s documents to understand the coverage and provisions
  • Identifying any violations of ERISA regulations by your plan administrator
  • Advising you on the strength of your claim and possible outcomes
  • Preparing comprehensive appeals for any claim denials
  • Gathering additional evidence to support your appeal
  • Communicating directly with the plan administrators on your behalf
  • Negotiating with the insurance company for a fair settlement
  • Representing you in any meetings or mediations
  • Filing a lawsuit in federal court if necessary
  • Protecting your rights throughout the legal process
  • Coordinating expert testimony to support your claim
  • Challenging any misinterpretations of plan terms by the administrator
  • Seeking the maximum possible benefits under your plan

Contact an ERISA Dispute Lawyer Now

Facing an ERISA insurance dispute can be tough, but you don’t have to go through it alone. At the Law Offices of Phillip A. Tatlow, LLC, we offer free consultations to help you understand your rights and options. Let us help you take the stress out of this process. Contact us today, and let’s work together to demand the results you deserve.

Contact Us

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.